Turner 談教育研究與教育理論
作者:lisky 日期:2010-04-28
Turner談教育理論
2010.4.5
李宗薇
當老師的吸引因素之一是有寒暑假。放假可休憩、可旅遊、可充電,老師的期盼心理一如學生。今年寒假不出國,又因新聞老早播報「史上最長的年假」,春節前就備妥想看的書及DVD,打算好好遨遊書海與影片。諸位或者想,看書、看DVD都很西松平常,何必要等過年?殊不知平日教學、研究、指導學生論文等將時間塞滿不說且切割的零碎,讀期刊論文都常被打斷,不似過年,看書觀影可一氣呵成,少被干擾。今年過年期間台北天氣濕冷,出遊不宜,但倒是讀書的好天氣,除了精神抖擻,思路也格外清晰。
先談Turner的教育理論(Theory of education)一書。
開宗明義,Turner先提2003年英國的社會科學研究報告,該報告的結論有二:其一為英國社會科學有大量且持續增加的研究已經及正在進行;其二,對於上述研究的批評也持續增加。而這種情形不是英國獨有,類似的討論在美國也可見。
Turner 引述學者及專業學術團體對教育研究品質的批評,多聚焦於教育研究者進行時不符合研究規範或應用不當,以致影響研究品質。但Turner認為目前社會科學研究,尤其是教育研究,應用的方法與原則不當,根本無法帶來高品質的研究。換言之,Turner質疑英、美的教育研究的問題不是研究者個人的問題,或是研究之「術」—研究方法或程序出紕漏,而是研究背後依據的理論架構有瑕疵,故他認為解決之道應從上游,也就是教育理論著手。
老實說,Turner對教育研究的看法用之於台灣也說得通。過去十餘年來,國內教育研究的論文、書籍等在數量上急增,但品質是否也一併提升,恐怕很難有正面答案。Turner書引起我注意的是,是他認為好的教育理論需符合下列標準:
1. 允許個人自由意志的範圍合乎倫理
2. 對於容許個人有超過一個以上的正確方法發展個人教育生涯(多面向)
3. 在瞭解的層級上,無論是個人及學校,或與更廣的社會之間,容許個人有部分的自主性(autonomy)
Turner 提出這三項規準,多少反映他認為目前教育理論太限制個人意志、太過決定論、太單一面向等。他以此三規準檢視教育理論,認為唯有先清除了地面,才能在上面植基、建立架構,進而容許教育研究發展建立可累積的傳統,在品質方面提升。
Turner 的教育理論三規準是否能成為教育研究的普世規準或通則,恐怕還需進一步的驗證。教育理論的對象是人,如欲以自然界的科學理論或原則套用在教育或社會學科,恐並不適宜。別忘了,教育是在脈絡之下進行,而脈絡又牽涉到社會、文化等因素,故教育理論要考量的因素既多且複雜,需要更全面、更仔細的檢視。
[本日誌由 lisky 於 2010-05-03 08:54 AM 編輯]
文章來自: 本站原創
引用通告地址: http://man.ntue.edu.tw/lisky/trackback.asp?tbID=96
Tags:
文章來自: 本站原創
引用通告地址: http://man.ntue.edu.tw/lisky/trackback.asp?tbID=96
Tags:
評論: 0 | 引用: 53035 | 查看次數: 381394
jordan low concords [2014-04-27 09:27 AM]
標題: jordan low concords
鏈接: http://www.donjononline.com/wp-content/lowconcord11s.php
摘要: half pieces of grain. A large box or bucket is the basis for
鏈接: http://www.donjononline.com/wp-content/lowconcord11s.php
摘要: half pieces of grain. A large box or bucket is the basis for
low concord 11s for sale [2014-04-25 04:31 PM]
標題: low concord 11s for sale
鏈接: http://www.brilliantpharma.com/images/jordan11lowconcord.html
摘要: In the final analysis, each person makes a choice of where to live based on the factors that he or
鏈接: http://www.brilliantpharma.com/images/jordan11lowconcord.html
摘要: In the final analysis, each person makes a choice of where to live based on the factors that he or
jordan 12 retro gamma blue [2014-04-23 02:26 PM]
標題: jordan 12 retro gamma blue
鏈接: http://www.jordan11lowconcordonline.com/jordan-12-retro-gamma-blue-T9085.html
摘要: Tiffany Brown singled to score Mary Beth Wilson in the second to give Georgia a 1 0 lead. "To whom
鏈接: http://www.jordan11lowconcordonline.com/jordan-12-retro-gamma-blue-T9085.html
摘要: Tiffany Brown singled to score Mary Beth Wilson in the second to give Georgia a 1 0 lead. "To whom
Real air yeezy 2 red october [2014-04-23 02:26 PM]
標題: Real air yeezy 2 red october
鏈接: http://www.jordanxilowconcord.com/real-air-yeezy-2-red-october-T9303.html
摘要: contract to assist able for a . While the Cost Of Living Allowance for Social Security (COLA) for
鏈接: http://www.jordanxilowconcord.com/real-air-yeezy-2-red-october-T9303.html
摘要: contract to assist able for a . While the Cost Of Living Allowance for Social Security (COLA) for
Air Jordan Pas Cher [2014-04-22 11:16 AM]
標題: Air Jordan Pas Cher
鏈接: http://www.led-lightingcn.fr/Air-Jordan-Son-Of-Mars-led-lightingcn-GG2262.html
摘要: Great website you have here but I was wanting to know if you knew of any forums that cover the same topics talked about in this article? I'd really love to be a part of community where I can get feedback from other experienced individuals that...
鏈接: http://www.led-lightingcn.fr/Air-Jordan-Son-Of-Mars-led-lightingcn-GG2262.html
摘要: Great website you have here but I was wanting to know if you knew of any forums that cover the same topics talked about in this article? I'd really love to be a part of community where I can get feedback from other experienced individuals that...
jordan low concords [2014-04-17 01:59 PM]
標題: jordan low concords
鏈接: http://www.jordanlowconcords.com/
摘要: User InterfaceRatingThough the design and the necessary
鏈接: http://www.jordanlowconcords.com/
摘要: User InterfaceRatingThough the design and the necessary
jordan low concord 11s 2014 [2014-04-17 01:41 PM]
標題: jordan low concord 11s 2014
鏈接: http://www.jordan11lowconcord.com
摘要: http://www.jordan11lowconcord.com order jordan 11 low concord
鏈接: http://www.jordan11lowconcord.com
摘要: http://www.jordan11lowconcord.com order jordan 11 low concord
Get women flint 13s Tickets [2014-04-11 12:36 AM]
標題: Get women flint 13s Tickets
鏈接: http://www.jordan11lowconcordforsale.com/get-women-flint-13s-tickets-T6594.html
摘要: from the saddle. originally a roaster, the company has
鏈接: http://www.jordan11lowconcordforsale.com/get-women-flint-13s-tickets-T6594.html
摘要: from the saddle. originally a roaster, the company has
Gucci Shoulder Bags [2014-04-08 10:55 AM]
標題: Gucci Shoulder Bags
鏈接: http://www.stuartlivingston.com/Gucci-outelt-online.html
摘要: started to warm toward Mr. Mr Swofford seems you would realize most ACC fans are
鏈接: http://www.stuartlivingston.com/Gucci-outelt-online.html
摘要: started to warm toward Mr. Mr Swofford seems you would realize most ACC fans are
發表評論
你沒有權限發表留言!
鏈接: http://www.jenningsperks.co.uk/news/wp-content/beatsbydreuk/
摘要: Such as the previous a single, John, you've nailed that once again. Thus interesting!