訂閱
上一篇
下一篇
抽籤是理性決定？
作者:lisky 日期:2014-08-08
抽籤是理性決定？
2014.8.8 李宗薇
期末考後學期結束放暑假了，考卷無從發回檢討。然身為老師，看到同學在申論題某些似是而非的觀念，覺得必須釐清。
學期剛開始時，得知該班因為沒人要當班代，故班代由抽籤產生，且中籤者並不在場。「教育媒體社會」期末考最後一題希望同學重新檢視抽籤決定班代這件事，希望經過一學期的研讀，同學有new light，可看出此事很多層(many layers)。但閱卷時看到有同學作答：「抽籤的方式並不是最理想的投票方法」、「每人應表達意見，以理性的角度看待此事，不是以完全理性的抽籤來完成」，這說法有誤謬，有進一步討論的必要。
1. 「抽籤的方式並不是最理想的投票方法」
文意上看，作答同學似乎認為抽籤是一種投票方法，只是不是最理想的。投票其實是做出選擇，對人或某議題，無論用舉手、記名、不記名、上網等方式，均反應投票人的立場並做出選擇；但抽籤不是個人選擇，不是投票方法，無論理想與否。
2. 「…以理性的角度看待此事，不是以完全理性的抽籤來完成」
作答者認為抽籤是「完全理性」，這恐是誤解了理性。
理性是指依據「證據」(evidence)而非情緒作決定。Max Weber說明理性是不以迷信、神秘、宗教等說法，而是依據科學及實際可計算的資料說明。抽籤雖非情緒，但基本上是依據機率(probability)或運氣，機率、運氣不是理性，更別說是完全理性。
上述這句話也前後矛盾，位階上，「完全理性」不是應比「理性」更高嗎？為何理性可否定「完全理性」？
進一步思考，如抽籤這麼「完全理性」，那麼人類何需費神思考各種制度、各種辦法；無論為職位找人，或制度建立，選拔人才，抽籤決定就好了，選總統、選市場、選鄉長、甚或大學校長皆可抽籤；大學入學、公費生留學等，皆抽籤，何需辦理指考、推甄？他國也可仿效，如美國高中生入大學何需申請、考SAT，一切抽籤決定就好，這才客觀、公平。是這樣嗎？
可我閱卷時也頗納悶，大多數的同學都表示抽籤產生班代似有不妥，但怎麼最後仍是抽籤產生？我「探究」可能的原因：「不要傷和氣」、「這不關我的事」；或者，雖主張抽籤的是少數，但他們聲音大，是班上意見領袖，無人敢撄其鋒…
這固然是該班的次文化與氛圍，但多少也反映現今年輕人的心態。
(原文在2014.7.4 本課程iCan 公告欄，略修改)
[本日誌由 lisky 於 2014-08-22 09:39 AM 編輯]
文章來自: 本站原創
引用通告地址: http://man.ntue.edu.tw/lisky/trackback.asp?tbID=164
Tags:
文章來自: 本站原創引用通告地址: http://man.ntue.edu.tw/lisky/trackback.asp?tbID=164Tags: 評論: 0 | 引用: 27211 | 查看次數: 294145
標題: Moncler Outlet Online
鏈接: http://www.kristengemenskap.com/moncler.asp
摘要: This is an great gift to on your family. I'd highly incourage individuals to buy our they will make a awesome gift. The sender can a great day task at acquiring ones things at occasion. I requested my personal items per day back and I also reveived...
鏈接: http://www.kristengemenskap.com/moncler.asp
摘要: This is an great gift to on your family. I'd highly incourage individuals to buy our they will make a awesome gift. The sender can a great day task at acquiring ones things at occasion. I requested my personal items per day back and I also reveived...
標題: http://bocoarchives.org/schuhe.asp
鏈接: http://bocoarchives.org/schuhe.asp
摘要: Recieved this particular product prior to the day provided in a really great gift container . The image that's revealed for the bracelet is actually exactly what you will recieve. That is most fragile though per breathtaking piece to precious jewel...
鏈接: http://bocoarchives.org/schuhe.asp
摘要: Recieved this particular product prior to the day provided in a really great gift container . The image that's revealed for the bracelet is actually exactly what you will recieve. That is most fragile though per breathtaking piece to precious jewel...
標題: cartier love bracelet replica
鏈接: http://www.computermetro.com.au/services.php
摘要: Recieved your item before the date presented in a really amazing gift package . The image that's displayed for the bracelet is exactly what you will recieve. This might be very sensitive yet the best gorgeous part to jewelry that will final as iof ...
鏈接: http://www.computermetro.com.au/services.php
摘要: Recieved your item before the date presented in a really amazing gift package . The image that's displayed for the bracelet is exactly what you will recieve. This might be very sensitive yet the best gorgeous part to jewelry that will final as iof ...
標題: Christian Louboutin Replica
鏈接: http://www.universalinstruments.com.au/AboutUs.aspx
摘要: It is an great gifts for your very own loved ones. I would highly incourage people to go for your things makes a ideal gifts. Some sort of transmitter performs a great evening duty with obtaining the particular stuff on top of occasion. I requested the...
鏈接: http://www.universalinstruments.com.au/AboutUs.aspx
摘要: It is an great gifts for your very own loved ones. I would highly incourage people to go for your things makes a ideal gifts. Some sort of transmitter performs a great evening duty with obtaining the particular stuff on top of occasion. I requested the...
標題: cheap louboutin shoes replica
鏈接: http://www.christianlouboutinoutlet.win/
摘要: Recieved this item before the date given in a really amazing present container . All picture that is revealed for the bracelet was what you certainly will recieve. This is quite fragile though one perfect part of precious jewelry which will final due t...
鏈接: http://www.christianlouboutinoutlet.win/
摘要: Recieved this item before the date given in a really amazing present container . All picture that is revealed for the bracelet was what you certainly will recieve. This is quite fragile though one perfect part of precious jewelry which will final due t...
標題: http://www.chow-monbrescant.com/fr/pigalle.asp
鏈接: http://www.chow-monbrescant.com/fr/pigalle.asp
摘要: Recieved the item prior to the date presented in a really wonderful gift package . The particular visualize that's shown for the bracelet was exactly what you certainly will recieve. This can be most sensitive but a striking section of jewelry whic...
鏈接: http://www.chow-monbrescant.com/fr/pigalle.asp
摘要: Recieved the item prior to the date presented in a really wonderful gift package . The particular visualize that's shown for the bracelet was exactly what you certainly will recieve. This can be most sensitive but a striking section of jewelry whic...
標題: http://www.ecova.es/weddingshoes.asp
鏈接: http://www.ecova.es/weddingshoes.asp
摘要: It is an awesome gift of ones loved ones. I would strongly incourage people to pick the information technology will make a ideal gifts. All transmitter does a good time task with acquiring the actual products upon occasion. I purchased the things a day...
鏈接: http://www.ecova.es/weddingshoes.asp
摘要: It is an awesome gift of ones loved ones. I would strongly incourage people to pick the information technology will make a ideal gifts. All transmitter does a good time task with acquiring the actual products upon occasion. I purchased the things a day...
標題: http://www.ttsq.fr/bottomshoes.asp
鏈接: http://www.ttsq.fr/bottomshoes.asp
摘要: This is an awesome gifts for the the family. I'd strongly incourage people to choose that things makes a awesome gifts. Their transmitter does outstanding time work in buying that the products regarding duration. I bought our things a day back and ...
鏈接: http://www.ttsq.fr/bottomshoes.asp
摘要: This is an awesome gifts for the the family. I'd strongly incourage people to choose that things makes a awesome gifts. Their transmitter does outstanding time work in buying that the products regarding duration. I bought our things a day back and ...
標題: http://www.cheapmoncler.xyz/
鏈接: http://www.cheapmoncler.xyz/
摘要: It is an great gifts for the family. I'd strongly incourage individuals to get our information technology makes a ideal present. That transmitter does a good time task with acquiring all stuff regarding time period. I requested our items a day ago ...
鏈接: http://www.cheapmoncler.xyz/
摘要: It is an great gifts for the family. I'd strongly incourage individuals to get our information technology makes a ideal present. That transmitter does a good time task with acquiring all stuff regarding time period. I requested our items a day ago ...
發表評論
你沒有權限發表留言！
鏈接: http://www.kajson.se/om-oss
摘要: Recieved this product before the time provided in a really awesome present box . Their visualize that is displayed for the bracelet is actually what you certainly will recieve. This will be most delicate yet one striking section to jewelry that will co...